PDA

View Full Version : Is it just me or is the Yaris engine THAT noisey?


detroiter
12-31-2011, 04:34 PM
I know 4cyl engines typically are pretty thrashy and rough sounding, atleast the economical ones (not the s2000, civic si's,etc) but seems like the Yaris is the exception. Seems like the Yaris engine is definitely on the loud and crude side, even more so in cold weather. What's your opinions?

RABYARIS
12-31-2011, 06:35 PM
On a scale of 0 to 10 (0 = perfect silence, 10 = baby screaming) I would give it a 6.

A-Dingo-Ate-My-Baby
12-31-2011, 07:23 PM
nope, not loud at all. pretty quiet.

Captain Slow
12-31-2011, 07:36 PM
I find it's one of the quieter motors I've seen.....with the exception of when you're really thrashing it.

jpmck03
12-31-2011, 07:54 PM
It's louder than my wife's Corolla, but I wouldn't consider the Yaris's engine to be super loud by any stretch of the imagination.

Hell, when it's at a stop and idling I'd say that it's rather quiet.

DMZ
12-31-2011, 08:56 PM
It is not as noisy as my Tundra.

detroiter
12-31-2011, 11:24 PM
Maybe not so noisey at idle or light acceleration..but medium and heavy acceleration, it sounds like your hurting the engine lol

UTVitz
12-31-2011, 11:31 PM
I've put 60K miles on mine and still fine the engine to be very quiet compared to most other vehicles in it's class. I did find early on trying different motor oils seemed to increase engine noise-don't know why, it was just an experiment and that's what stuck out the most. The thing that still impresses me the most is how quiet the a/c compressor is-no loud click or hissing sounds under the dash as in some vehicles.

I did find the new chevy sonic and ford fiesta to be very quiet, but I believe it was mostly due to sound deadening in the firewall and not the engine being any better design. Neither the Yaris nor Honda Fit use a lot of sound deadening which saves on weight and cost, but adds noise when accelerating. Now that I think about it both the sonic non-turbo and fiesta use costly, pain in the butt timing belts and it's always been said they are quieter in operating than a timing chain as the Yaris has.

Gogogordy
01-01-2012, 12:31 AM
I've put 60K miles on mine and still fine the engine to be very quiet compared to most other vehicles in it's class. I did find early on trying different motor oils seemed to increase engine noise-don't know why, it was just an experiment and that's what stuck out the most. The thing that still impresses me the most is how quiet the a/c compressor is-no loud click or hissing sounds under the dash as in some vehicles.

I did find the new chevy sonic and ford fiesta to be very quiet, but I believe it was mostly due to sound deadening in the firewall and not the engine being any better design. Neither the Yaris nor Honda Fit use a lot of sound deadening which saves on weight and cost, but adds noise when accelerating. Now that I think about it both the sonic non-turbo and fiesta use costly, pain in the butt timing belts and it's always been said they are quieter in operating than a timing chain as the Yaris has.


Noise suppression is indeed one of oils' primary job duties. Also cleansing, cooling, and off course providing a microscopic barrier between mating surfaces.

SilverBack
01-01-2012, 12:43 AM
I actually find mine pretty quiet up to about 3K RPM (I once turned the ignition by accident when it was already idling). Also keep in mind that because it only outputs 106 horsepower at the crank, the gears are shorter. Go over 60 MPH and it's bound to scream a little.

Flipper_1938
01-01-2012, 02:31 AM
The Yaris has more engine noise than the echo (same engine).

The stock yaris intake is simpler than the echo intake. I think that is where most of the noise comes from.

thebarber
01-01-2012, 02:47 AM
after going back to a stock exhaust i noticed how annoying the engine sounds...

bronsin
01-01-2012, 08:45 AM
What a shame the motoring public (and reviewers like Edmunds) thinks this is important.

The engine in the Yaris/ECHO is the best small engine on the market today. Its 1.5 liters and makes 106 hp and, in an ECHO (lighter than the Yaris) with manual transmission, capable of 40 mpg around town and 53 mpg on the highway at 60-65 mph. With a different cylinder head, it is also about the same engine used in the origional Prius.

By contrast the engine in the ~1973 BMW 2002, which was thought to be a marvel in its day, was 2 liters, fuel injected, and produced 100 hp. What mileage it got I dont know because I was too young to drive/own one.

But it wasnt 40 mpg you can bet on that. Probably more like 25 mpg.

The ammount of noise an engine makes is irrelevant. Whats important is how reliable it is and, today especially, how economical. This engine makes phenominal power and delivers state of the art fuel economy. On TV commercials other car companies (Ford and Hyundai) are (fraudulently) claiming their cars are 40 mpg capable.

I guess the same people who think the engine in our cars is noisy believe that too!

Captain Slow
01-01-2012, 12:10 PM
having owned two Miatas I can tell you they have some valve-tapping buzzy little motors too, but they're excellent motors nonetheless.

Hamster
01-01-2012, 01:02 PM
Noise suppression is indeed one of oils' primary job duties. Also cleansing, cooling, and off course providing a microscopic barrier between mating surfaces.

Anybody know which brand of oil is best at reducing noise? I'd like to try it out the next time I do an oil change.

bronsin
01-01-2012, 01:12 PM
Why that would be Bronsin Oil. At $100 a quart its a bargain!


Here what you do. When you find the Quietest Oil we'll put some in one Yaris and something else in 99 other Yaris's.


But we wont tell you which one it is.

You find it.

Hamster
01-01-2012, 01:32 PM
Why that would be Bronsin Oil. At $100 a quart its a bargain!


Here what you do. When you find the Quietest Oil we'll put some in one Yaris and something else in 99 other Yaris's.


But we wont tell you which one it is.

You find it.

Hah, hah! :laugh: I was just curious about that comment, if using specific brands makes a noticeable difference, especially given that I just changed my oil just yesterday.

UTVitz
01-01-2012, 02:00 PM
When I first became aware the engine sounded different right after an oil change was the same time I first experimented with full synthetic back in '08. I had no bias as what to try as I had always used Valvoline conventional. But I did not like how Valvolines syntec sounded as well as Mobile One-they gave my engine a gritty sound that was not there when conventional was in the same engine. I decided cost no object I'll try Redline (I never changed weight it was always 5w-30 no matter what brand) and my ear heard the difference. Yes, it's a few dollars more than other brands, but since the car only holds 3.5 qts. I like the smooth quiet it gives my motor.

Yury
01-01-2012, 02:31 PM
The Yaris has more engine noise than the echo (same engine).

The stock yaris intake is simpler than the echo intake. I think that is where most of the noise comes from.

+1 on that, mine is pretty buzzy under load and it does sound like intake noise.

overall, yes, this engine is on the loud side. quiet when not loaded, but under any kind of load the noise is definitely starts to come through. I find that I have to adjust the radio volume more often than in other cars I had. But it's ok, it's not too bad.

swidd
01-01-2012, 11:21 PM
Put sound proofing butyl on the inside of the engine hood, and on the firewall in the footwells and around the gear shifter area (resonating surfaces between the seats/footwells).

Captain Slow
01-01-2012, 11:36 PM
sound dampening does do wonders. I remember using a small piece of carpet under the shift boot of my '84 Prelude and it did wonders for the cabin noise.

JumpmanYaris
01-02-2012, 12:16 AM
nope, not loud at all. pretty quiet.

HOLY F@$% for once i agree with ya :clap:

salmonz
01-03-2012, 10:32 PM
Sometimes I find myself turning down the radio when it's OFF. The engine is a bit noisy when driving compared to other vehicles. I agree, 6 would be the rating out of 10 (0 quiet, 10 loud).

Hershey
01-04-2012, 12:19 AM
The Shell synthetic 5w-30 tames it . Now have the SHELL 5w-20 (SN ) syn and that's a tad noisier than the 5w-30 . The sedan really seems to like the 5w-20 . Plan to get an used oil analysis done within a few months to see if any more wear than with the 5w-30 . Hopefuly not . Will post the U.O.A. .

ljming99
01-04-2012, 05:09 AM
HOLY F@$% for once i agree with ya :clap:

I would agree it is quiet.

I did not do any additional sound proofing.

But with simolta SRI, and fujitsubo wagolis muffler. The idling is very quiet.

Even cruising at 100km/h @ 3k rpm is fine too.

So i suppose a stock yaris is pretty quiet - for a bread/butter car.

So much better than my previous Aveo (1.4 etec engine).

ljming99
01-04-2012, 05:11 AM
Sometimes I find myself turning down the radio when it's OFF. The engine is a bit noisy when driving compared to other vehicles. I agree, 6 would be the rating out of 10 (0 quiet, 10 loud).

A number of experienced mechanics and those workshops here locally working with toyota engines will tell you to do an oil change, it works wonders on this tiny 1.5 vvti =D

bronsin
01-04-2012, 07:24 AM
You must have got bad ones. Mine is as quiet as a mouse. It DID make a little noise on accelerating when I got it.

But that was gone by 1000 miles.

Highway Star
01-05-2012, 04:07 PM
My last two cars I drove for ten years each. In the early nineties I bought a 91 chevy sprint turbo new, excellent car but the engine was loud. Then again it was an early 90's econo car.

Next was a 95 geo tracker used (suzuki sidekick) 2dr convertible hardtop. I lifted it, put bigger tires, a header with 2" exhaust. I drove that thing hard everywhere, it had next to no insulation from the engine or outside noises. It was noisey, and it rode stiff like a military truck. I drove it for ten years, and just sold it two weeks ago.

I've only been driving the yaris for two weeks now. Let me tell you guys & gals that the yaris is as quiet, and rides as smooth as a bentley :headbang: no kidding, it's that big of a difference to me. I bought it used, an 07, so the first thing was to change the oil to synthetic. I bought it from a nissen dealer, and wanted to make sure I got 5W-30 into it. The oil place I go to uses quaker state, so I used 5W-30 synthetic. and must say there was a difference in how the engine sounded from a cold start to cruising. The synthetic oil made a small difference but noticeable. Also it might have had thicker grade of oil in it too from the dealer or previous owner, you never know what's in it when you buy used.

bronsin
01-05-2012, 05:05 PM
I've only been driving the yaris for two weeks now. Let me tell you guys & gals that the yaris is as quiet, and rides as smooth as a bentley :headbang: no kidding, it's that big of a difference to me.
.


I think you pretty much have to run it to the limit through the gears to get the noise some people are talking about.

I almost never exceed 45 mph and I take my sweet time getting there.

I hardly hear the engine myself.

Hershey
01-05-2012, 11:45 PM
We've always had small cars , so no big deal .

thebarber
01-06-2012, 07:03 AM
Its noisy under load...or at 70mph

mikescuba
01-06-2012, 07:15 AM
I recently changed my front tyres and I have noticed it has got a little more noisy. I can't complain about my Yaris though. It is a 2001, 1 ltr petrol engine and has done just over 350.000 klm. I never changed the spark plugs till it had done 225.000 Klm. Changed brake pads at 250.000 and the back wheel bearings at 320.000. I have replaced the battery twice. Other than that all I have done is change the oil and filter every 15.000 Klm. Somewhere along the line I did change the air filter and its just about to be changed again as there was a problem with the pollution for the MOT. It doesn't use any oil between servicing and I think it still has a lot of life still left in it.

bronsin
01-06-2012, 07:19 AM
Thats what we need here the 1 liter gas engine. They should charge LESS for it too.

Everyone has diesel engine on the brain. But diesel here in NJ is ~$3.69 a gallon while gas is ~ $3.10.

BAck in the 90s when diesel was 79 cents a gallon and gas was 99 cents yeah, diesel was the nuts. I could fill my 240D (20 gallons) for $16!

Those days are GONE.