2010 higher mileage or 2008 lower mileage?

[chocolab]

Been a member here for a while but never bought my Yaris. Kind of chickened out last fall and got a different car, but the Yaris attraction never went away. Now I'm getting more serious about getting one again.

Have two cars in mind right now, both listed for about the same price. NADA on each is very close. Both are the same color, both have the same power package and split rear seat (which is important to me), but one is a 2010 with about 75k miles and one is a 2008 with about 54k miles. History report on both looks good.

Which would you choose? In the past I'd probably have gone for the lower miles, but my inclination here is actually to go for the 2010, mainly because I like the tach (manual transmission) and prefer the 2010's different upholstery. Plus I need to add cruise and from what I've read here it's easier on the 2010.

Am I off base? Which would you choose?