In the market for a new car. Need help picking - Toyota Yaris Forums

VaultTec · 06-29-2016, 05:13 PM

Im currently in the market for another car that will be used only by me as a work commuter, weekend / fun car. I have no intentions of having tons of crap in the trunk or passengers all the time (only my wife and that would be rarely). So a cramped car is fine by me. I own a 2016 Yaris SE so I fell in love with the small car feel. Must be a coupe or hatch back. Budget hopefully under 25K. I look forward to hearing what you guys gotta say. Open to ideas, suggestion and comments!

One thing I wanted to add is I plan on buying the car brand new. I hate used cars. The only exception on this list for that would be the Yaris.

My choices so far are.. (In order of which I want most)

1) Fiat 500 Abarth
2) Ford Fiesta ST
3) Another Yaris
4) Toyota Prius C

*kimona* · 06-29-2016, 05:30 PM

While the Fiat 500 Abarth and Fiesta ST are neat little "performance" cars, both suffer from absolutely miserable reliability ratings. I like to spend my money wisely... and avoid issues that can be extremely frustrating, so neither of those models would be contenders.

bronsin · 06-29-2016, 05:54 PM

My vote is $8-10k for a used Yaris!

BLKHILLSGUY · 07-02-2016, 02:33 AM

I would patiently wait for the supposed new upcoming Prius C. That is what I am interested in. The new Prius is getting 52 mpg. So the C will likely do better than that. It's about time for a compete redesign. There is also talk that that the Prius wagon and/or C could both will be killed off. But more likely at this point that the C will return to live on another generation. I would NEVER buy a Fiat. Cute as shit, funky interior, horrid reliability. I also kind of like the new Smarts. Although they say they aren't Toyota reliable either.

BLKHILLSGUY · 07-02-2016, 02:34 AM

And Fiesta's are also funky but very unreliable.

Exiwolfman · 07-02-2016, 09:13 AM

I vote for a new Yaris SE, but the Prius C in traffic will save you on gas just a little just dont think the price difference is worth the savings in gas. At least here in Canada its a 10k jump in price .

NEexpat · 07-02-2016, 10:06 AM

Corolla,
Proven reliable platform, good gas mileage, does not feel small, although it doesn't fit the coupe/hatch component, the Corolla is often overlooked.

Kalispel · 07-02-2016, 04:56 PM

Personally, I'm shackled with the need for both reliability/quality AND aesthetic/driving appeal in my car choices, along with subcompact/compact stature (and preferably hatchback) - so my choices are next to zero presently. There literally isn't a new car out there currently, using my personal criteria, that I would want other than a Yaris SE (which isn't perfect either). All the others have either reliability/quality going for them OR aesthetic/driving appeal, OR neither (at least in my eyes).

If you don't want another 2015/2016 Yaris SE (understandable, since you already have one), then hold off and see what the new 2017 Yaris Hatch brings (hopefully not a fugly hatchback iA), or the 2017 Corolla refresh (the current one is fugly). There is also the new Toyota C-HR coming in 2017, which is a funky little compact crossover hatch. I haven't decided yet if I like the look of it or not.

NEexpat · 07-02-2016, 05:08 PM

^ yeeech, don't care for rear windows like that. It looks like a Nissan Juke and a Pontiac Aztec had a Demon spawn. From breaking bad, to breaking bad taste.

Another option, hatch, not really a sub but a crossover that my gf, who currently drives a FIT, is looking at is the Honda HRV.

The one she looked at came in right around USD $ 25K.

*I actually like the Juke, just wish it wasn't built by Nissan.

*kimona* · 07-02-2016, 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kalispel

There is also the new Toyota C-HR coming in 2017, which is a funky little compact crossover hatch. I haven't decided yet if I like the look of it or not.

Holy shite... that's fugly! I just don't get the current Toyota/Lexus design trend.

junorico24 · 07-02-2016, 07:05 PM

I would get

Mazda 3 sp25/ mps
Mazda2
VW Golf R
Toyota Caldina import
Nissan Pulsar SSS turbo.

CoryM · 07-02-2016, 10:06 PM

From your list I would go for the Fiesta if you want fun, and the Yaris if cost/reliability is more important. The Fiats are..... not great mechanically.

They are getting big, but maybe consider a Civic Si? The other option is to maybe take a cheaper car and spend the extra $$$ to modify it to do what you want.

Exiwolfman · 07-02-2016, 10:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoryM

From your list I would go for the Fiesta if you want fun, and the Yaris if cost/reliability is more important. The Fiats are..... not great mechanically.

They are getting big, but maybe consider a Civic Si? The other option is to maybe take a cheaper car and spend the extra $$$ to modify it to do what you want.

Also Nissan Micra , cheap car at 9999.00 $Canadian

Sent from my ONEPLUS A3000 using Tapatalk

invader166 · 07-02-2016, 11:24 PM

Hmmm...interesting dilema...

My answer, why not have both a hatchback and coupe in one?

I would consider either a Scion tC or a Hyundai Veloster.

Exiwolfman · 07-02-2016, 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by invader166

Hmmm...interesting dilema...

My answer, why not have both a hatchback and coupe in one?

I would consider either a Scion tC or a Hyundai Veloster.

Tc a better choice

Sent from my ONEPLUS A3000 using Tapatalk

VaultTec · 07-07-2016, 03:39 PM

I managed to test drive all the cars I've mentioned.

1. I pretty much fell in love with the Fiat Abarth. The ONLY complaint I would have is the plastic dash that's colored based on the exterior. Other than that. Possibly the best and most fun driving experience I ever had. Addressing the reliability. It has a decent warranty 4 years 50k miles. So once it expires. I'll likely be trading it in. I have 2 other cars so it being in the dealer getting repairs isn't too much of an issue. That being said. I've heard mixed reviews about it. Just one of those things you gotta try out yourself.

2. The Ford Fiesta ST was the car I was most interested in actually seeing / driving. Since I've already driven a regular Fiat 500 (non Abarth) so I had an idea of how that car was. I was badly disappointed. The interior looked so outdated, cheap, cluttered and boring. Not really liking the new body styles of Ford. The ride was stiff and overall meh. It does have slightly better specs on paper but in the real world I doubt it'll be noticeable or matter.

3. I drove a 2008 or 07, can't remember, Yaris. Let me just say. Wow. Compared to my 2016 SE. It feels like another car. Definitely felt the sub compact feel that I don't really feel in my current Yaris. Performance wise, it's a Yaris. Didn't expect much but it did have some kit. I think it's the trd kit? So much potential in that car. Loved it. Don't really want another 3rd gen or any future newer Yaris unless they come beefed up from factory with a new model, like a RS Or whatever. Hopefully turbo charged.

4. The Yaris C was much like the Yaris. Only more complex, slower and got better MPG. Not much to say here. It'll get to me to point A to B feeling meh. Good car nevertheless.

5. I drove an older Scion tC as someone here mentioned. Not the newer body. Don't know the year. It was actually surprisingly good. Definitely have to look into it more. So I will be adding that to the maybe list.

ern-diz · 07-07-2016, 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VaultTec

3. I drove a 2008 or 07, can't remember, Yaris. Let me just say. Wow. Compared to my 2016 SE. It feels like another car. Definitely felt the sub compact feel that I don't really feel in my current Yaris.

Sounds like you mean this as a negative, right? Haven't driven one for myself, but from what I've gathered, the 2nd gen's offer a minimalist, visceral driving experience while the 3rd gen's are more refined, which some would also call boring. I'd like to experience it for myself.

I'm hurting for a Focus RS. It's well out of the price range we're talking about, but because of my interest in it, the Fiesta ST jumped out at me from your short list. I like that Ford was the only US auto maker not to take bailout money, I think they pack good tech/features in for the money and I like where the styling has gone across all their models. I think they look far better than Acuras, which I think have taken a dreadful downturn in styling. As much as I like the looks and performance of the Abarth I wouldn't go Fiat. Prius is probably your best bet economically speaking.

brushforhire · 07-07-2016, 05:52 PM

I just got an 07 VW rabbit/golf and love it. Also I work for Mopar/fiat dealer and would not touch a Fiat with a 20 foot pole.

06-29-2016, 05:13 PM	#1
VaultTec Drives: 2016 Yaris SE Join Date: May 2016 Location: California Posts: 28	In the market for a new car. Need help picking Im currently in the market for another car that will be used only by me as a work commuter, weekend / fun car. I have no intentions of having tons of crap in the trunk or passengers all the time (only my wife and that would be rarely). So a cramped car is fine by me. I own a 2016 Yaris SE so I fell in love with the small car feel. Must be a coupe or hatch back. Budget hopefully under 25K. I look forward to hearing what you guys gotta say. Open to ideas, suggestion and comments! One thing I wanted to add is I plan on buying the car brand new. I hate used cars. The only exception on this list for that would be the Yaris. My choices so far are.. (In order of which I want most) 1) Fiat 500 Abarth 2) Ford Fiesta ST 3) Another Yaris 4) Toyota Prius C

06-29-2016, 05:54 PM	#3
bronsin Drives: 2009 Base Hatch 2 Dr Auto Join Date: Dec 2008 Location: nj Posts: 4,790	My vote is $8-10k for a used Yaris! __________________ Synthetic Oil: Its All In Your Head

07-02-2016, 05:08 PM	#9
NEexpat Drives: 2009, auto, 4dr LB Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: S.E. New England Posts: 292	^ yeeech, don't care for rear windows like that. It looks like a Nissan Juke and a Pontiac Aztec had a Demon spawn. From breaking bad, to breaking bad taste. Another option, hatch, not really a sub but a crossover that my gf, who currently drives a FIT, is looking at is the Honda HRV. The one she looked at came in right around USD $ 25K. I actually like the Juke, just wish it wasn't built by Nissan. Last edited by NEexpat; 07-02-2016 at 05:20 PM.*

07-02-2016, 11:24 PM	#14
invader166 Pumpman Drives: 2019 Kia Soul EV Base Join Date: Dec 2014 Location: Langley, BC Posts: 434	Hmmm...interesting dilema... My answer, why not have both a hatchback and coupe in one? I would consider either a Scion tC or a Hyundai Veloster. __________________ "I would rather loose by a mile in a car I built myself, then win by an inch in a car that was built for me." - Moog

07-07-2016, 05:52 PM	#18
brushforhire Drives: 07 HB YARIS, 15 JUKE, 00 TUNDR Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Johnstown, PA Posts: 320	I just got an 07 VW rabbit/golf and love it. Also I work for Mopar/fiat dealer and would not touch a Fiat with a 20 foot pole. __________________ Project so far: 2zrfe swap, Megan racing coilovers, TRD rear sway bar, whiteline bushings, RPM long tube header, midpipe, and DC sports xD exhaust, brake upgrade in front, MI stainless braided lines all around, matte paintjob, Takada cold air intake, various gauges, rear seat and belts removed. Future: Turbo.

06-29-2016, 05:30 PM	#2
kimona Super Moderator Drives: 2014 White VITZ Join Date: May 2007 Location: Huntington Bch, CA Posts: 4,938	While the Fiat 500 Abarth and Fiesta ST are neat little "performance" cars, both suffer from absolutely miserable reliability ratings. I like to spend my money wisely... and avoid issues that can be extremely frustrating, so neither of those models would be contenders.

07-02-2016, 02:33 AM	#4
BLKHILLSGUY Drives: 2011 3dr LB Polar White Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Black Hills of South Dakota Posts: 344	I would patiently wait for the supposed new upcoming Prius C. That is what I am interested in. The new Prius is getting 52 mpg. So the C will likely do better than that. It's about time for a compete redesign. There is also talk that that the Prius wagon and/or C could both will be killed off. But more likely at this point that the C will return to live on another generation. I would NEVER buy a Fiat. Cute as shit, funky interior, horrid reliability. I also kind of like the new Smarts. Although they say they aren't Toyota reliable either.

07-02-2016, 02:34 AM	#5
BLKHILLSGUY Drives: 2011 3dr LB Polar White Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Black Hills of South Dakota Posts: 344	And Fiesta's are also funky but very unreliable.

07-02-2016, 09:13 AM	#6
Exiwolfman View User's Garage Drives: 2007 Yaris Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Wasaga beach Posts: 1,617	I vote for a new Yaris SE, but the Prius C in traffic will save you on gas just a little just dont think the price difference is worth the savings in gas. At least here in Canada its a 10k jump in price .

07-02-2016, 10:06 AM	#7
NEexpat Drives: 2009, auto, 4dr LB Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: S.E. New England Posts: 292	Corolla, Proven reliable platform, good gas mileage, does not feel small, although it doesn't fit the coupe/hatch component, the Corolla is often overlooked.

07-02-2016, 04:56 PM	#8
Kalispel View User's Garage Drives: '15 Yaris SE 5MT Join Date: Jun 2014 Location: Arizona (USA) Posts: 1,058	Personally, I'm shackled with the need for both reliability/quality AND aesthetic/driving appeal in my car choices, along with subcompact/compact stature (and preferably hatchback) - so my choices are next to zero presently. There literally isn't a new car out there currently, using my personal criteria, that I would want other than a Yaris SE (which isn't perfect either). All the others have either reliability/quality going for them OR aesthetic/driving appeal, OR neither (at least in my eyes). If you don't want another 2015/2016 Yaris SE (understandable, since you already have one), then hold off and see what the new 2017 Yaris Hatch brings (hopefully not a fugly hatchback iA), or the 2017 Corolla refresh (the current one is fugly). There is also the new Toyota C-HR coming in 2017, which is a funky little compact crossover hatch. I haven't decided yet if I like the look of it or not.

07-02-2016, 07:05 PM	#11
junorico24 Drives: toyota yaris yrs Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Sydney Posts: 642	I would get Mazda 3 sp25/ mps Mazda2 VW Golf R Toyota Caldina import Nissan Pulsar SSS turbo.

07-02-2016, 10:06 PM	#12
CoryM Drives: 2009 5-door, 5-speed Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: White Rock BC Posts: 687	From your list I would go for the Fiesta if you want fun, and the Yaris if cost/reliability is more important. The Fiats are..... not great mechanically. They are getting big, but maybe consider a Civic Si? The other option is to maybe take a cheaper car and spend the extra $$$ to modify it to do what you want.

07-07-2016, 03:39 PM	#16
VaultTec Drives: 2016 Yaris SE Join Date: May 2016 Location: California Posts: 28	I managed to test drive all the cars I've mentioned. 1. I pretty much fell in love with the Fiat Abarth. The ONLY complaint I would have is the plastic dash that's colored based on the exterior. Other than that. Possibly the best and most fun driving experience I ever had. Addressing the reliability. It has a decent warranty 4 years 50k miles. So once it expires. I'll likely be trading it in. I have 2 other cars so it being in the dealer getting repairs isn't too much of an issue. That being said. I've heard mixed reviews about it. Just one of those things you gotta try out yourself. 2. The Ford Fiesta ST was the car I was most interested in actually seeing / driving. Since I've already driven a regular Fiat 500 (non Abarth) so I had an idea of how that car was. I was badly disappointed. The interior looked so outdated, cheap, cluttered and boring. Not really liking the new body styles of Ford. The ride was stiff and overall meh. It does have slightly better specs on paper but in the real world I doubt it'll be noticeable or matter. 3. I drove a 2008 or 07, can't remember, Yaris. Let me just say. Wow. Compared to my 2016 SE. It feels like another car. Definitely felt the sub compact feel that I don't really feel in my current Yaris. Performance wise, it's a Yaris. Didn't expect much but it did have some kit. I think it's the trd kit? So much potential in that car. Loved it. Don't really want another 3rd gen or any future newer Yaris unless they come beefed up from factory with a new model, like a RS Or whatever. Hopefully turbo charged. 4. The Yaris C was much like the Yaris. Only more complex, slower and got better MPG. Not much to say here. It'll get to me to point A to B feeling meh. Good car nevertheless. 5. I drove an older Scion tC as someone here mentioned. Not the newer body. Don't know the year. It was actually surprisingly good. Definitely have to look into it more. So I will be adding that to the maybe list.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Unique Smell from Air Going Through AC Blower	EddieCabael	DIY / Maintenance / Service	30	01-19-2015 09:08 PM
What Car Mechanics Don't Want You to Know!!	daddz07	DIY / Maintenance / Service	16	04-17-2011 10:10 PM
Tsunami	MAD DOG	Hawaii	11	03-13-2011 08:14 PM
Photo-Scavenger Hunt - THE LIST	Black Yaris	Photo-Video-Media Gallery	22	03-04-2009 08:35 PM