2012 Yaris, anyone else have high insurance?

[Chifte]

Has anyone else had expensive insurance quotes for these cars?

I'm 25, traffic ticket at 21 for 9 over. I tend to get a more premium insurance plan, I'm getting $1,700 -$2,000 a year insurance quotes from Progressive, Geico, Allstate, Donegal. When I was 17 I had two tickets(one as 80 in a 25) in a couple months, paid only $800 a year for almost the same coverage. At 19 I bought a new Focus, had $900 a year same coverage as this Yaris while getting a speeding tickets and never had an increase.

I'm just curious, makes no damn sense. Listed as one of the cheapest cars to insure by many websites, I'm quarter century old, good safety ratings, no recent tickets and I'm getting quotes similar to a 17 year old in a WRX STI.