If you were me which would you pick?

[Kalispel]

I would wait on the new 2019 Corolla hatch myself. It's only a few months off at this point. The Australian version is bound to be better than the U.S. version, just as the iM-Auris-Corolla hatch version was better in Australia in the upper trims. Still, those fake exhaust ports on the new 2019 hatch are annoyingly tacky.

Not a fan of the Toyota 86 here - reminds me of those cheap-looking kit-cars from the 1980's for some reason. I also can't stand the Honda Fit, for quite a few different reasons - but, regardless of the eyesore factor, perhaps the version in your market is better than the garbage ones that Honda sells here in the U.S. I would buy a 2018+ black Yaris SE over anything you listed up top, in a heartbeat - but then I do have very different taste in cars than most people it would seem.